How Much Is My Circle Y Saddle Worth?

Circle Y saddles are a popular brand of horse saddle. These saddles are well built, typically made out of leather with high-quality stitching and sturdy construction which makes them more valuable than other brands.

And that is the reason even old circle y saddles are often sold at cowboy stores and online retailers at pretty reasonable prices. And if you’re looking for one or want to sell the one you might come up with the question how much is my circle y saddle worth?

The most important factor in determining the value is the age of the saddle. If you have a new or used Circle Y saddle that has never been ridden then it will be valued at $2,000-$4,000. Used saddles with wear and tear from riding may only be worth $700-$1,200 depending on their condition.

To find out exactly how much a saddle costs we need to dig a little deeper. So let’s find out.

When did Circle Y start making saddles? & Who invented It?

Originally, Circle Y started making saddles in 1960. This company was founded by Leland Tucker, who started Circle Y from scratch with a mission to manufacture the best quality saddles of all time.

Circle Y has been manufacturing saddles in Yoakum, Texas since its early days.

How to Know How Much Old/Used Circle Y Saddle Worth?

Sometimes calculating the worth of a used saddle can be a bit difficult. Especially when you don’t have any previous experience of buying used saddles. That’s why it’s necessary to estimate the price of a used Circle Y Saddle, before making a purchase.

You can easily determine the worth of a used saddle by checking a few things. These things mainly consist of a saddle’s age, build quality, model, and condition.

Let’s take a detailed look at these factors for better understanding.

1. Age of a Saddle: How Can You Tell How Old a Saddle is?

The age of your saddle plays an important role in its selling price. If you have a newer saddle then you have a higher chance to sell it at a good price.

Meanwhile, old saddles are also sold frequently but as compared to new ones they don’t stand a chance.

You can find out the age of your saddle by checking its serial number. Circle Y saddles have their serial number printed on a metal plate located on the left side just below the seat jockey.

2. Check the Price of the Same Model: Do all Circle Y saddles have a serial number?

The next thing is to check the current price of the model that you want to sell. Circle Y produces saddles with different models. And the price of a saddle varies depending upon its model. Some saddles come at a lower price, while some cost a fortune.

In short, you have to find out the original price of your model. Once you compare the new saddle to your old one, it will be easy for you to know its worth.

In case you aren’t sure about the model number, you can find it out through the serial number of your saddle. You can decode the serial number to get more information about your saddle.

Almost all of the Circle Y saddles come with a serial number. I am not sure about the older ones. But the recently manufactured models do have a serial number printed on a metal plate (attached to your saddle).

3. Design of a Saddle

With the evolution in technology, the average saddle design has also changed. Previously saddles were constructed with a simplistic design. But, over the decades manufacturers have added extra features in saddles to make them more comfortable for riders as well as for horses.

That is why potential buyers are interested to purchase saddles with modern design so that they can have a comfortable experience.

So, before selling your saddle know about its design. In this way, you will be able to get a good price for it.

4. Condition of a Saddle: How Do I Know If My Circle Y Saddle is in a Good Condition?

The next important thing that determines the worth of your old saddle is its condition. Firstly, check the leather quality of your Circle Y saddle if it’s fine or if the stitches look perfect. If you have been using it for quite some time then there are some chances that the leather may look worn out.

In case the leather is thick and flexible then it means it’s fine and there’s nothing to worry about.

After you’ve done with the leather, check the seat, cantle, tree, and pommel of your saddle. Most importantly, the tree must be in sturdy condition because it’s the inner and central part that provides stability to the saddle. If the tree seems to be broken or something doesn’t seem right then get it fixed from a cowboy store.

These things deploy a huge effect on the worth of your used saddle. So, make sure that everything is fine with your saddle.

Where Can I Sell My Circle Y Saddle? Where can you buy Old Saddles in Good condition?

Now that you are aware of your saddle’s worth, the next step is to sell it or buy it. When it comes to selling a Circle Y saddle or buying a used one, you can either visit a nearby local shop or by using online marketplaces.

Selling through an online marketplace will be easier. Some websites like eBay, Craigslist, and Sport Horse Nation. You can create an ad describing the features and conditions of your saddle. After that, you can post it on any of these websites. Also, keep on checking your ad posting to see if there is any potential buyer or not.

Some trusted sources to buy old saddles in good condition include eBay, Craigslist, and Facebook Groups (people often post ads about their saddles).

If you plan to buy one you can do the same search for used saddles for sale on craigslist or used saddles for sale on eBay. There you’ll find pretty good quality English and western saddles in the price range of $100 to onward.

You can also give a try Amazon but there are not as many stocks available as on craigslist or eBay.


If you want to know how much my circle Y saddle is worth value, the answer can be a bit complicated.

There are many factors that affect the saddle value such as age, and condition, but also what you paid for it when purchasing or how old your Saddle Y was when purchased.

Finding an average price for the old saddle is difficult as there are so many variables in play. In general, though, used saddles cost between $700-$1200 dollars depending on these factors mentioned above.

On the other hand, if you’re in the market to buy a used Saddle Y there are plenty of options out there that can be found on craigslist and eBay.

You should also consider what type of saddle you’re looking for – Western or English saddles have different types of designs that might appeal more to certain people. But no matter which style you choose, always take the time to inspect the saddle before buying so you know exactly what condition it’s in and whether or not it’s right for you!